Antigone
Essay by review • March 7, 2011 • Research Paper • 1,925 Words (8 Pages) • 1,514 Views
Antigone and Ismene are were given the same opportunity for redemption. If this play is looked at from a contextual point a view, we could say that the respect for the Gods and afterlife was the number one priority. During the first scene of the play Antigone, we see the character differences of Antigone and Ismene as they take different stances on what to do about polyneceis.
Antigone and Ismene have different motivations for their actions in life, which come from their value of human life or the afterlife.
Citatiation : Antigone: There it is, and now you can prove what you are: a true sister, or a traitor to your family.
Ismene: Bury him! You have just said the new law forbids it.
Citation Antigone: I say that this crime is holy. . . . It is the dead, not the living, who make the longest demands: we die forever . . .you may do as you like, since
apparently the laws of gods mean nothing to you.
Ismene: but I have no strength to break laws that were made for the public good.
Antigone is viewed as brash and not as meticulous as Ismene
Citation Ismene: You must tell no one, I will keep it a secret, I promise!
Antigone " Oh tell it! Tell everyone! Think how they'll hate you when it all comes out if they learn that you knew about it all the time!
Explanation (Ismene wants to keep this behind closed doors, but Antigone is not going to work that way, they could have planned a further term goal to bury them. If they had let the king not bury them, he would have been in just as much trouble with the gods)
Citation: Ismene: Impossible things should not be tried.
Explanation: Ismene has reasoned that burying her brother so quickly is impossible with the Creon so recently making the decree.
In the second act, Ismene displays marked fear for the wrath of her uncle, directly contrasting with Antigone's courageous intent to defy his orders and bury her brother.
Citation Ismene: But think of the danger! Think what Creon will do!
Antigone: Creon is not strong enough to stand in my way. 875
Explanation: Antigone is boasting her fearlessness of Creon while Ismene is openly admitting fear of him.
Ismene: I am so afraid for you!
The story of Antigone is more than a tragic tale of the aftermath of Oedipus' grisly demise. Antigone, a woman of strong will and spirit, and her sister, Ismene, a quieter woman of rational propriety and practical judgment, are shown as two unlikely protagonists with differing approaches to their brother's death, one of the main conflicts in the play. While both maintain the best of intentions, their differing opinions creates much of the tension seen in the play, between themselves and their uncle, King Creon, who begins the conflict by refusing to bury their dead brother properly, denying him entrance into the afterlife. The reactions the sisters display when presented with the possible consequences of their actions, or also in this case, inactions, prompt the personality differences in their individual personas to become clear. Ismene and Antigone's opposing reactions to King Creon's decree reveal their opposing character traits.
One of the first opposing traits that these sisters share concerns their differing emotional approach to the death of their brother, defined by one sister's brash actions and the other sister's reasonable restraint. "Have they told you the new decree of the king?" Antigone asked Ismene at the beginning of the play (875). Antigone is first introduced as emotionally distraught when she tells her sister about the decree of the king. Antigone sees this as her chance to properly bury her brother and willingly disregards her own life to insure that he is sent to the Afterlife. There could have been future opportunities for Antigone to do it, but she had to be impulsive against the King's decree instead of reasoning with him first. Antigone ends her conversation with Ismene, admitting to her plans being "foolish" and that she is "not afraid of the danger; if it means death" (877). This type of reasoning must be brash and "unwise" since she values life and death equally. While Antigone is impulsive and rash about burying her brother, Ismene is considering the possible repercussions of Antigone's proposed actions and wary of what punishments could ensue if she were to follow through. "But think of the danger! Think what Creon will do," is Ismene's response to Antigone's brash actions (875). "So fiery, you should be cold with fear" (876). Ismene is taking a very conserved and thoughtful stand point by saying this. She wishes that her sister could be more calm and calculated enough to think of a plan with out death. There is even a point where Ismene calls the mission "impossible" and deems it hopeless (876). This isn't to say that Ismene doesn't support Antigone though. "I will keep it a secret, I promise!" (876). She is willing to cover for Antigone rather than be loyal to the king. Ismene still believes that Antigone's cause is noble and that she is being a "loyal friend indeed to those who love" Antigone (877). While Ismene also recognizes that she could be punished for her sister's actions, she still refrains from inhibiting her sisters from burying their brother. The intentions behind her reasoning become apparent soon after, when the fear of her uncle emerges after she changes her mind in her next scene.
When Ismene changes her mind, she can be looked upon as fearful from her regrets. "I am equally guilty" (886). Ismene asks to be punished the same as Antigone because she would rather die an honorable death than to be hated by the dead. There are times where our fears are what drive us to do what is right, and Ismene must have had enough of fearing what would happen to her in the afterlife, since she denied nothing when arrested. "I too have a duty that I must discharge to the dead" (886). There is a new fear of what will happen to her in the afterlife, as opposed to what will happen to her in the present, which shows us that Ismene is now acting only in reaction to what she believes she should fear the most. Her fears dictate her actions at this point, which contrasts with Antigone's steadfast
...
...