Excerpt from Russell's Why I Am Not a Christian
Essay by review • December 29, 2010 • Essay • 343 Words (2 Pages) • 1,242 Views
Russell's conclusion is "Ð'...and therefore you do not get any advantage by introducing God as an intermediary." Ð''God as an intermediary' in this excerpt implies Ð''God having a reason'. This attachment of meaning occurs in 2, below.
Russell asks the question, "Why did God issue just those natural laws and no others?" Two answers appear: A. Ð''God had no reason.' and B. Ð''God had a reason.' He dismisses answer A quickly: if there was no reason, then there are no Ð''laws' and the opening question is not valid. His argument for answer B follows: 1. God had a reason for giving natural laws (to make the best universe); 2. if there was a reason for God-given law, then God was subject to law; 3. therefore no advantage by introducing God as an intermediary. As the premises do not guarantee the truth of the conclusion, this is an inductive argument.
A needed background supposition is the belief that a being that has reason gets that reason from a higher-level being, hence its intermediateness. An ultimate being can have reason on its own. I sometimes imagine I have reason on my own.
Weakness in the argument can be found in, "Ð'...if there was a reason for the laws which God gave, the God himself was subject to law, and therefore Ð'... by introducing God as an intermediary." God can have a reason for creating a law that God is not required to follow; the reason can come from Ð''within' God, it need not be external. Having a reason does not necessarily make God an intermediary. 2 , a sub-conclusion, is required to accept the conclusion, but 2 does not have to be true.
Russell's opening sentence presupposes we are aware of all God's laws; perhaps we are aware of but a few. We only know what we know; just because we do not know a thing, of it or about it, does not preclude its existence. This presupposition is another weakness in the argument. Is is true that we are aware of all laws God has ever issued?
...
...